The 2018 Maine gubernatorial election took place on November 6, 2018, to elect the governor of Maine. It occurred along with elections for the U.S. Senate, U.S. House, and other state and local elections. Incumbent Republican Governor Paul LePage was term-limited and could not seek a third consecutive term. He later unsuccessfully sought a third term in 2022. This was one of eight Republican-held governorships up for election in a state carried by Hillary Clinton in the 2016 presidential election.
The primaries for this election were the first in Maine to be conducted with ranked choice voting (RCV), as opposed to a simple plurality, after voters passed a citizen referendum approving the change in 2016. An advisory opinion by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court held that RCV would be unconstitutional for general elections for governor and the state legislature. This led state legislators to vote to delay its implementation pending approval of a state constitutional amendment. Backers of a "people's veto" turned in enough signatures to suspend this law until a June referendum vote, which restored RCV for future primary and congressional elections.
Governor Paul LePage threatened not to certify the results of the primary elections, saying he would "leave it up to the courts to decide." He also called the use of ranked-choice voting the "most horrific thing in the world." Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap said the results would be binding regardless of whether LePage certified them.
The Republican nominee was businessman and 2010 independent candidate for governor Shawn Moody. The Democratic candidate was Attorney General Janet Mills. State Treasurer Terry Hayes and businessman Alan Caron had qualified for the ballot as independents, though Caron dropped out on October 29 and endorsed Mills. Former state senator and former mayor of Lewiston and Auburn John Jenkins and perennial candidate Kenneth Capron ran write-in campaigns.
Mills defeated Moody and Hayes with a majority to become the first female governor of Maine. This was the first election since 2006 that Maine elected a Democratic governor. Mills was also the first gubernatorial candidate to win at least 50% of the vote since Angus King in 1998, and the first non-incumbent to do so since Kenneth M. Curtis in 1966. Mills received more votes for governor than any other candidate in Maine history, becoming the first Maine gubernatorial candidate to earn 300,000 votes. This was the first gubernatorial election since 1982 that a Democrat would win a majority of the popular vote.
The 2018 Maine gubernatorial election took place on November 6, 2018, to elect the governor of Maine. It occurred along with elections for the U.S. Senate, U.S. House, and other state and local elections. Incumbent Republican Governor Paul LePage was term-limited and could not seek a third consecutive term. He later unsuccessfully sought a third term in 2022. This was one of eight Republican-held governorships up for election in a state carried by Hillary Clinton in the 2016 presidential election.
The primaries for this election were the first in Maine to be conducted with ranked choice voting (RCV), as opposed to a simple plurality, after voters passed a citizen referendum approving the change in 2016. An advisory opinion by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court held that RCV would be unconstitutional for general elections for governor and the state legislature. This led state legislators to vote to delay its implementation pending approval of a state constitutional amendment. Backers of a "people's veto" turned in enough signatures to suspend this law until a June referendum vote, which restored RCV for future primary and congressional elections.
Governor Paul LePage threatened not to certify the results of the primary elections, saying he would "leave it up to the courts to decide." He also called the use of ranked-choice voting the "most horrific thing in the world." Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap said the results would be binding regardless of whether LePage certified them.
The Republican nominee was businessman and 2010 independent candidate for governor Shawn Moody. The Democratic candidate was Attorney General Janet Mills. State Treasurer Terry Hayes and businessman Alan Caron had qualified for the ballot as independents, though Caron dropped out on October 29 and endorsed Mills. Former state senator and former mayor of Lewiston and Auburn John Jenkins and perennial candidate Kenneth Capron ran write-in campaigns.
Mills defeated Moody and Hayes with a majority to become the first female governor of Maine. This was the first election since 2006 that Maine elected a Democratic governor. Mills was also the first gubernatorial candidate to win at least 50% of the vote since Angus King in 1998, and the first non-incumbent to do so since Kenneth M. Curtis in 1966. Mills received more votes for governor than any other candidate in Maine history, becoming the first Maine gubernatorial candidate to earn 300,000 votes. This was the first gubernatorial election since 1982 that a Democrat would win a majority of the popular vote.
Background
Incumbent Republican Paul LePage was term-limited, having been elected twice consecutively in 2010 and 2014. LePage did not win a majority of the vote either time (receiving 37.6% in a crowded four-way race in 2010 and 48.2% in a three-way race in 2014), with Democrats accusing independent candidate Eliot Cutler of splitting the anti-LePage vote in both instances, though Cutler finished closer to LePage than Democratic candidate Libby Mitchell in the 2010 election.
Maine's history of governors elected without majorities, including LePage, was one impetus for the citizen's referendum to implement ranked choice voting. Indeed, the last time a gubernatorial candidate received a majority of the vote was in 1998, when incumbent governor (and current United States Senator) Angus King, an independent, won reelection with 58.6% of the vote. The last time a non-incumbent candidate received more than 50% of the vote was the 1966 gubernatorial election, which Democrat Kenneth M. Curtis won over incumbent Republican John H. Reed with 53.1% of the vote.
Though ranked-choice voting was approved by voters in a 2016 referendum, the Maine Legislature voted to delay and potentially repeal RCV for all elections after an advisory opinion by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court ruled it unconstitutional for general elections for state offices. RCV supporters succeeded in a people's veto effort to prevent the delay, which suspends it until a June 2018 referendum vote. RCV supporters were victorious in the June referendum, and ranked-choice voting will remain in place for state and federal primaries and federal general elections.
Republican primary
Speculation that U.S. Senator Susan Collins was considering running for governor arose during the 2015 Maine Legislative session when Representative Matt Moonen (D-Portland) introduced a bill to strip the governor (LePage at the time) of the power to appoint replacement U.S. Senators in the event of a vacancy and to instead have a special primary and general election. Moonen denied that he was motivated by Collins's possible candidacy, saying he was interested only in counterbalancing Republican-sponsored bills to change how the Maine Attorney General and Maine Secretary of State are chosen. Moonen said Collins had told him speculation about her running for governor was "silly." Collins, who was the 1994 Republican nominee for Governor, told MPBN News on January 4, 2016, that though she was "baffled" by the rumors about her being interested in running for governor, many had encouraged her to run, and she would not rule it out. In October 2017, Collins said she would not run for governor in 2018.
No Republican candidate ruled out challenging the results of a ranked-choice primary in court. Mary Mayhew called for the immediate repeal of RCV, calling it a "scam" and "probably illegal".
The Maine Republican Party filed a federal lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Bangor on May 4, 2018, seeking to bar the use of RCV for its own primary on the grounds that requiring the party to use it violates its First Amendment rights to choose its nominee as it sees fit. U.S. District Court Judge Jon Levy rejected the suit on May 29.
Candidates
Nominated
Shawn Moody, businessman and independent candidate for governor in 2010
Eliminated in primary
Ken Fredette, state house minority leader
Garrett Mason, state senate majority leader
Mary Mayhew, former commissioner of the Maine Department of Health and Human Services
Withdrawn
Deril Stubenrod, write-in candidate for the U.S. Senate in 2014
Mike Thibodeau, Maine Senate president
Declined
Rick Bennett, former chairman of the Maine Republican Party, former President of the Maine Senate, candidate for the U.S. Senate in 2012 and nominee for ME-02 in 1994
Susan Collins, U.S. senator and nominee for governor in 1994
Nick Isgro, Mayor of Waterville
Bruce Poliquin, U.S. representative (ran for reelection)
Peter Vigue, businessman
Endorsements
Ken Fredette
Federal politicians
Marco Rubio, United States senator from Florida and 2016 presidential candidate
Garrett Mason
Federal politicians
Ted Cruz, United States senator from Texas and 2016 presidential candidate
Mary Mayhew
Federal politicians
Newt Gingrich, former Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Local and state politicians
Susan Austin, state representative
Richard Bradstreet, state representative
Richard Campbell, state representative
Paul Chace, state representative
Garrel Craig, state representative
Scott Cyrway, state senator
Robert Foley, state representative
Phyllis Ginzler, state representative
James Hamper, state senator
Jeffery Hanley, state representative
Matthew Harrington, state representative
Stephanie Hawke, state representative
Gary Hilliard, state representative
Chris Johansen, state representative
Jonathan Kinney, state representative
Bob Macdonald, former mayor of Lewiston
Richard Malaby, state representative
Beth O'Connor, state representative
Lester Ordway, state representative
Michael Perkins, state representative
John Picchiotti, state representative
Jeffrey Pierce, state representative
Dwayne Prescott, state representative
Deborah Sanderson, state representative
H. Stedman Seavey, state representative
Abden Simmons, state representative
Paula Sutton, state representative
Timothy Theriault, state representative
Karleton Ward, state representative
Other individuals
Adrienne Bennett, former spokesperson for governor Paul LePage
Democratic primary
Almost all Democratic candidates said that they would abide by the results of the ranked-choice primary, with only Janet Mills refusing to comment on the issue because it was being heard by the courts.
Candidates
Nominated
Janet Mills, Maine Attorney General
Eliminated in primary
Adam Cote, attorney, Iraq War veteran and candidate for ME-01 in 2008
Donna Dion, former mayor of Biddeford
Mark Dion, state senator and former Cumberland County Sheriff
Mark Eves, former Speaker of the Maine House of Representatives
Diane Russell, former state representative
Betsy Sweet, former director of the Maine Women's Lobby
Failed to make ballot
Dominic A. Crocitto
Steve DeAngelis, schoolteacher
J. Martin Vachon
Withdrawn
James Boyle, former state senator
Patrick Eisenhart, retired United States Coast Guard Commander
Sean Faircloth, former mayor of Bangor and former state senator
Kenneth Forrest Pinet
Declined
Justin Alfond, former state senator and former President of the Maine Senate
Yellow Light Breen, CEO of the Maine Development Foundation
Adam Goode, former state representative
Troy Jackson, State Senate Minority Leader
Stephen King, author
Chellie Pingree, U.S. Representative
Hannah Pingree, former Speaker of the Maine House of Representatives
Lucas St. Clair, nonprofit executive (ran for ME-02)
Endorsements
All endorsers are Democrats unless otherwise specified.
Adam Cote
Federal politicians
Tom Allen, former US Representative for ME-01, nominee for US Senate in 2008
Local and state politicians
Justin Alfond, former President of the Maine Senate
Peter Baldacci, Penobscot County Commissioner
Frank Bemis, former Presque Isle Town Council Chair
Todd Brackett, Sheriff of Lincoln County
Michael Brennan, former mayor of Portland, former state senator, candidate for ME-01 in 2008
Marilyn Canavan, state representative
Alan Casavant, Mayor of Biddeford, former state representative
Justin Chenette, state senator
Janice Cooper, state representative
Tom Cote, Mayor of Sanford
Annie Graham, former state representative
Jon Hinck, former state representative and former Portland City Councillor
Adam Lee, former Auburn City Councillor
David Lemoine, former state representative
Nate Libby, state senator, Senate Minority Whip
Colleen Madigan, state representative
Anne-Marie Mastraccio, state representative
Patrick K. McGowan, former state representative, candidate for Governor in 2010, nominee for ME-02 in 1990 and 1992, former Small Business Administration Regional Administrator
Cynthia Mehnert, Orono Town Councillor
Cecil Munson, former Augusta City Councillor
Kevin O'Connell, Brewer City Councillor
Peter O'Donnell, former Mayor of Portland
Patrick Paradis, former state representative and former Augusta City Councillor
Josh Plourde, former Bangor City Councillor
Christina Riley, state representative
David Rollins, Mayor of Augusta
Michael Sanphy, Mayor of Westbrook
Stephen Stanley, state representative
Spencer Thibodeau, Portland City Councillor
Dan Tremble, Bangor City Councillor
Anna Turcotte, Westbrook City Councillor
Linda Valentino, state senator
Wayne Werts, former state representative
Organizations
Maine Council of Machinists
Newspapers
Bangor Daily News
Steve DeAngelis (failed to make ballot)
Individuals
Timothy Simons, actor
Mark Eves
Local and state politicians
Joe Baldacci, former Bangor City Councillor
Seth Berry, state representative
Dale Denno, state representative
Patrick Eisenhart, former gubernatorial candidate (2018)
Sean Faircloth, Bangor City Councillor, former Mayor of Bangor, former state senator, former gubernatorial candidate (2018)
Richard Farnsworth, state representative
Ryan Fecteau, state representative
Roger Fuller, state representative
Drew Gattine, state representative
Anne Haskell, former state senator
Erik Jorgensen, state representative
Chuck Kruger, former state representative
Thomas Longstaff, state representative
Louis Luchini, state representative
Jay McCreight, state representative
Jennifer Ellen Parker, state representative
Deane Rykerson, state representative
Linda Sanborn, former state representative
John Alden Spear, state representative
Ben Sprague, Mayor of Bangor
Joan Welsh, former state representative
Individuals
Adam Lee, small business owner and environmental activist
Warren Silver, former Maine Supreme Judicial Court justice
Organizations
Iron Workers Local 7
Working Families Party (also endorsed Sweet and Russell)
Janet Mills
Local and state politicians
Joseph E. Brennan, former governor of Maine (1979–1987), former US Representative for Maine's 1st congressional district (1987–1991), former Maine Attorney General (1975-1979), nominee for Governor in 1990 and 1994, nominee for US Senate in 1996, candidate for Governor in 1974
Lynn Bromley, former state senator
Emily Cain, former state senator, nominee for ME-02 in 2014 and 2016, executive director of EMILY's List
Margaret Craven, former state senator
Jerry Davis, former state representative
Lois Galgay Reckitt, state representative
Dawn Hill, state senator
Helen Rankin, former state representative
Other individuals
Maura Healey, Massachusetts Attorney General
Nick Wilson, executive director, Maine Gun Safety Coalition
Organizations
Emily's List
Betsy Sweet
Local and state politicians
Everett "Brownie" Carson, state senator
Clare Davitt, Bangor City Councillor
Beth Edmonds, former President of the Maine Senate
Karen Kusiak, former state representative, candidate for State Senate
Dale McCormick, former Maine State Treasurer, former state senator, candidate for ME-01 in 1996
Ethan Strimling, Mayor of Portland, former state senator, candidate for ME-01 in 2008
Mike Sylvester, state representative
Charlotte Warren, state representative
Barb Wood, former Portland City Councillor, vice president of the Equality Maine Foundation
Other individuals
Ben Cohen, cofounder, Ben & Jerry's
Cenk Uygur, journalist, host of The Young Turks
Marianne Williamson, writer
Organizations
Southern Maine Democratic Socialists of America
Working Families Party (also endorsed Eves and Russell)
Green Independent primary
Candidates
Withdrawn
Jay Parker Dresser, candidate for ME-02 in 2016
Betsy Marsano, activist
Libertarian primary
Candidates
Withdrawn
Gilbert P. Doughty
Richard Light
Independents
Candidates
Declared
Kenneth A. Capron, perennial candidate, systems analyst and fraud investigator^(write-in candidate)
Terry Hayes, Maine State Treasurer
John Jenkins, former mayor of Lewiston, former mayor of Auburn and former Democratic state senator^(write-in candidate)